Paper vs Plastic? Or Cotton vs Canvas?

It’s now a trend: the reusable grocery bag. I am beginning to see grocery stores selling canvas bags for $1 a piece. I fathom that those prices will increase when (or if the “pay a quarter per plastic bag” law passes).

WholeFoods has already taken a step towards this “banning plastic at the checkout” concept. By Earth Day, April 22, 2008 their 270 U.S., Canadian, and British based stores will be officially asking their customers “What type of reusable bag do you have today?” instead of “Paper or plastic?”

But before many of us jump on the bandwagon, why not look at a few statistics on plastic first? According to the American Chemistry Council:

  1. 2,000 plasic bags weigh 30 pounds vs 2,000 paper bags weigh 280 pounds. Therefore, plastic bags take up less landfill.
  2. Delivery of paper bags vs plastic bags: seven trucks vs only truck to deliver the same amount of plastic bags. This means less energy and less emissions into the environment.
  3. The manufacture of paper bags uses 70% more air emissions than plastic bags.
  4. Plastic bags generate 80% less waste than paper bags.
  5. 815 Million pounds of plastic and film was recycled in 2006 – an increase of 24% from 2005.

So what’s all this hype on banning plastic bags in grocery stores about? Even retailers such as Walmart offer plastic bag collection bins at the front of the store. The problem is, we as a society in general do not recycle enough. Don’t you see all those poor beat up plastic bags hanging from the tree branches? No, they are budding flowers. In the US alone, approximately 100 Billion bags are used per year, of which most ends up sitting in our landfills for 1,000 years.

And I haven’t even said my prayers for all those innocent marine animals that choked and died from eating pieces of plastic. You would think that they would know the difference between jellyfish and plastic but apparently, they don’t.

So what’s the catch-all solution? BYOB: Bring Your Own Bag (Sorry party animals. In this case, the acronym does not mean bring your own beer).

If you want to jump on the BYOB bandwagon, and don’t want to spend a lot of money on buying one or want to bring a trendy looking one, here are some places where you can find great patterns on creating your own reusable shopping bags. But you may need to know how to sew, knit or crochet.

Whipup.net – Keep a wallet-sized fold-up shopping bag with you at all times.
Creative Kismet – Shows you how to turn your old pillowcases into a cute shopping bag.
morsbags.com – Download easy to follow instruction on how to sew your own cloth bag.
houghtonavenue.com – A knitted grocery bag for a cottony shopping experience.

Bring Your Own Bag. What an excellent concept.

Enjoyed reading this article? Click here for other Earth Friendly articles.

Posted on 18 April 2008 by Judy Sommers in Featured Stories, Green Talk

2 Comments For This Post

  1. Nadine says:

    BYOB indeed. Here in Luxembourg (Europe) they made it practically mandatory: the government gave each household one reusable bag, and after that, any reusable bag is 80c or a non-reusable 3c (of course they’re a lot smaller). This is in supermarkets, smaller shops don’t have to charge for the plastic bags, which now are also distributed by the government and have an embarrassing message on them (sth like ‘yes, I forgot my bag’).

    My mother (and I) were using the reusables before anyhow, but the government campaign worked: the number of people using the reusables has quadrupled. The richest nation in the world is extremely stingy and does not like paying 3c for something they used to get for free. Now non-reusables are the exception, it’s typically someone going in for a few items. But anyone doing the weekly shop has the reusables with them.

    Well done government (for once)…

  2. juicyfruit says:

    I love the “yes, I forgot my bag” idea. I think those organic/natural stores such as Whole Foods should implement this idea since folks that go to these stores tend to be more Earth friendly.

    I am definitely seeing a lot more canvas bags for sale, even at our biggest wholesale stores such as Costco. It’s great.

    The thing that I don’t understand about some major corporations, who can probably afford to pay for a few recycling bins to be strategically placed through out the facility, is that they won’t allow some of the cleaning crew keep the recyclables. See my blog: http://journals.gagazine.com/juicyfruit/corporate-america-and-recycling/

    We celebrate Earth day, but they spend lots of money on printing out flyers and buying little knick knacks as gifts to their employees. Why not spend that money on recycling bins so we can put our soda cans and bottles in there? I just don’t get it.

Leave a Reply



Advertise Here

RELATED ARTICLES:


Low Cost Green Halloween Costume Ideas

When you’re searching for green costume ideas for Halloween, there are a couple of different approaches you can take.  You can choose a green, or earth friendly theme.  Or you can choose organic or eco-friendly materials to make your costume from.  Here are a few ideas from each category. Some of the most obvious green themes […]


Go Green Without Breaking Your Piggy Bank

What are some of the ways in which you can go “greener” without breaking your budget? Here are a few suggestions. […]


The Trash Can Game: Teaching Your Kids to Reduce Trash

Like anything else, teaching your children to be “green” starts at an early age. What better way to teach them than to integrate it into their daily routine? This “game” can be played in a group setting such as a classroom or with just your child alone. Before starting the “game” however, you should […]


History of Earth Day

While celebrated sometimes both in the fall and spring (equinoctial Earth Day), the Earth Day as we know it, is officially celebrated on April 22nd, and dates back to the year 1970. Earth Day commemorates the birthday of the modern environmental movement and celebrates the United States recognition to preserve the Earth. Since then, its […]


8 Tips To Keep Your Child Safe In The Outdoors

As much as parents would like to protect a child against illness and injury, this may be difficult, especially when potential health hazards can be found everywhere. Although this may be the case, parents can still do so much in protecting a child when outdoors. While child proofing is possible indoors, a parent can still […]